There’s a particular phrase that shows up again and again in homes that raise confident, capable kids, and it has nothing to do with praise, rewards, or even love in the way we usually talk about it. The phrase is simple: “Could you do me a favor?”
Rav Shlomo Wolbe draws a distinction that many parents miss because it looks like a contradiction at first. On one hand, he’s a strong advocate for clear hierarchy in the home — there’s a reason many communities in Eretz Yisrael have children stand when a parent enters the room, or speak to parents in the third person the way they’d address a Rav. “Would Abba like a cup of water?” instead of “Do you want a cup of water?” These customs exist precisely to make something clear: there are parents, and there are children, and that distinction matters.
But Rav Wolbe immediately pairs that with something that looks like the opposite: in specific, limited moments, you make the child your actual partner. When it comes to making the challah, the child is your partner. When it comes to taking care of the baby, the child is your partner. When it comes to planning the family’s camp trip, the child is your partner. And Rav Wolbe says plainly — this elevates the child. It makes them great.
Why Both Things Are True at Once
This isn’t inconsistency. It’s precision. A child who never experiences hierarchy grows up without boundaries, without the healthy sense that some decisions aren’t his to make yet. But a child who only experiences hierarchy — who is always managed, never consulted, never genuinely needed — grows up small. He never gets to feel what it’s like to be relied upon.
The favor is the hinge between the two. When you say, “Could you do me a favor,” you’re not issuing a command from above; you’re making a request, the way you’d ask a peer. The child registers that distinction instantly, even if he couldn’t articulate it. For a few minutes, he’s not being managed — he’s being needed.
What This Looks Like This Week
- Hand over a real task, not a fake one. Kids can tell the difference between being given a “job” to keep them busy and being given a task that actually matters to the family — kneading the dough, holding the baby while you answer the door, picking the route for a family outing. Real stakes, even small ones, are what create the feeling of partnership.
- Use the language of request, not command, for these moments specifically. “Could you do me a favor and help me get this ready?” lands completely differently than “Go do this.” Save the direct instructions for the things that are genuinely non-negotiable, and reserve the favor-language for the partnership moments.
- Let the outcome actually depend on them, a little. If a child helps plan a family trip, let some of his ideas visibly show up in the plan. If he’s “in charge” of greeting Shabbos guests at the door, let that actually be his job that night, not something you hover over and redo.
- Keep the hierarchy intact everywhere else. Partnership moments work precisely because they’re not the norm — they’re a deliberate elevation out of the ordinary structure of the house, which is what makes them feel significant.
Parents sometimes worry that giving a child too much say will erode respect or authority. Rav Wolbe’s framework suggests the opposite outcome when it’s done with intention: a child who is trusted with real responsibility in specific moments doesn’t lose respect for the structure around him — he grows into someone worthy of trusting with more of it over time.
If you’d like more of these practical, text-based insights into Torah parenting, come join the inner circle at lawrencekelemen.com.
This blog was co-written with Artificial Intelligence.